6 Comments
User's avatar
Jay Es's avatar

excellent analysis as always Harry. This is very ridiculous bureaucracy at work. 100% we need this. LA is already so complex for pickups, would be great to have more options and increase efficiency for us returning or arriving passengers.

Patrick Hillberg's avatar

I notice that you’re not showing a street view of the LAX departures area? This is a zoo, and I avoid LAX for this reason alone. Have often thought that there should be a people mover from the terminals to the rental area. (It’s coming in January?) The area needs fewer cars, not more. I see a case where what appeals on an individual level does not work systematically.

And that is an area which requires a lot of situational awareness. Robotaxis have not proven strong at this.

Harry Campbell's avatar

Yes there are way too many cars in the horseshoe at LAX but why should a private vehicle get preference over Uber/Lyft or Waymo? Congestion will never get better unless you try to solve the root cause a la decongestion pricing.

And yes Waymo does sometimes lack situational awareness but they're operating at several other airports without major incident, so why would LAX be any different? Clearly it's less of a technical barrier and more of a regulatory one. Kind of telling that there's not even an application or permit process available to Waymo if they wanted to apply to operate at LAX. Inexcusable imo.

Patrick Hillberg's avatar

“Horseshoe” - you may have answered your own question.

Some quick math on my part… let’s say there are 33 gates at LAX, each embarking and disembarking 150 passengers (total 300) per hour. If each passenger is PUDO’d using a single vehicle, LAX would need to handle 10,000 slow-moving and stopped vehicles per hour.

Through something called “the horseshoe”. 😳

And SAVs have not proven adept at situational awareness in difficult environments. Note the issues of passing school busses and lines of parents waiting for school pickup, and in one situation hitting a child near a school.

For each plane delivering 150 people to/from a concentrated airport, you maybe want 5 buses of 30 dispersing them away from the property? I’m not a fan of private vehicles there either.

(And e.g., PHX is in the middle of a desert. It’s not bounded by an ocean on one side. Hence the horseshoe.)

Michael McFerrin's avatar

Harry, you are an active Waymo customer? Seriously?

Harry Campbell's avatar

Yes, great product. Have you taken a ride?